What is non-recognition aggression in cats?

You come home from the veterinarian with one cat, release it into your home, and then the staring, stalking, and hissing, or even worse, starts. Many cat owners have experienced this scenario and wonder what just happened. These cats have known and lived together for years without any issues. And now one cat is chasing the other; you hear growling and hissing. 

Non-recognition aggression is aggressive behavior toward a cat the aggressor has previously gotten along with without any problems. This can be a sibling or another familiar cat the aggressor has lived with in the same home for several months or even years, with no tension easily detectable by the cat parent. 

Non-recognition aggression is not well researched, and many myths and anecdotal stories surround this type of non-predatory aggressive behavior in cats.

When we talk about aggressive behavior in cats, researchers typically distinguish between predatory and non-predatory aggression. Predatory behavior, as the name suggests, is directed toward prey with the goal of feeding the animal or its offspring. Non-predatory behavior is directed toward humans, other cats, or a different species for various reasons. 

When can it happen?

This aggressive behavior is typically reported when one cat returns home from a vet visit while the other cat stayed home. But it can also happen when one cat goes to the groomer or has a sleepover with another family member. Generally, it can happen anytime one cat leaves the familiar home and the familiar scent pattern is disrupted. 

Most cases of non-recognition aggression are reported after vet visits, according to the few research papers that have examined this type of aggression. This may indicate that the scent in a vet clinic is more disruptive, or that vet visits are simply the most common reason cats are temporarily separated. 

What is causing non-recognition aggression?  

We don’t know for sure. As mentioned before, non-recognition aggression has not been researched at all, and most information comes from case studies and personal experiences. Given how heavily cats rely on scent, non-recognition aggression is likely caused, at least in part, by a disruption of a familiar scent pattern. The scent and sight of a familiar cat are conditioned stimuli. A conditioned stimulus (CS) is a previously neutral stimulus that, through repeated pairing with an unconditioned stimulus, elicits a specific response. This process is a core part of classical conditioning, first studied by physiologist Ivan Pavlov. The cat has learned that the other cat is not a threat, and somehow this conditioning/learning has been reversed by:

-       The overall unfamiliar scent of the veterinary clinic, groomer, or other home

-       Scent from disinfection and cleaning products used on the vet exam table

-       Scent from grooming products

-       Medications and vaccines administered during the vet visit

-       Smell of anesthesia medications like ketamine after surgeries

-       The scent of stress hormones released after a vet visit

-       The scent of other animals and people encountered during the stay outside the home

Humans may not be able to detect the distinct scent of a homecoming cat. We may be able to smell some scents, like disinfectants or medications. But the homecoming cat most likely smells significantly different from the perspective of the cat that stayed home. 

And the cat who has returned home may also look or behave differently.

-       Wearing a cone after surgery

-       Having part of the body shaved after surgery or grooming

-       Still lethargic or sleepy after surgery

How can you prevent or manage non-recognition aggression, or help your cat quickly return to baseline?

As so often with behavior cases, the answer is, it depends. It depends on how severe your case of non-recognition aggression is: Did you notice one incident and just some staring, with no hissing or stalking? Did one cat stare, stalk, and chase the other cat for a few hours or days?

Did you have to visit the vet for bite wounds?

The spectrum of non-recognition aggression cases is wide. As with cat introduction cases, the worse the situation is, the harder it will be to recover.  

Here are some practical tips to either prevent or lessen the impact of non-recognition aggression:

1.     Keep the cats separated in different rooms, with no visibility to each other, until they act calmly again and you don’t notice any lethargy or medication smell. Be patient – this can take hours or days. Each cat should have his own litter box, food and water, and bedding. 

2.     Slowly introduce them once calmed down. Observe any signs of aggressive behaviors. A tail up is typically a good indicator that things are going well.

3.     Do not let them "fight it out". Fighting only creates traumatic negative associations and deepens the conflict.

4.     If you notice any fighting or negative signs, separate again immediately: Gently block or herd the aggressor into a separate, quiet room. Give both cats several hours and days to decompress.

5.     Prevent re-escalation: Keep them apart until the aggressor is completely calm and the returning cat has had time to wear off any vet or grooming smells. 

6.     If the incidents worsen, be prepared to administer behavior medications and/or switch to a mobile vet that comes to your home.

7.     Be prepared for the next vet visit

-       If you have upcoming vet visits, plan to keep the cats separated for a few hours or even days.

-       Monitor their body language and separate them if you see any signs of staring, stalking, or worse.

-       If possible, think about mobile vet appointments. In my experience, it works well with cats that are sensitive to this type of behavior.

-       Discuss behavior medications with your veterinarian.

Digging deeper into case studies:

When clients come to me about aggressive behavior between two cats, it often turns out to be a case of non—recognition aggression. One cat returned from the vet, and the problems started. When I ask more about these two cats’ history together, the owners often recall and share similar incidents of animosity after a vet visit. Sometimes it is barely noticeable to an untrained eye: some staring, stalking, or piloerection that lasts only a couple of hours. Then things become noticeably worse. When we talk about the cats’ relationship, it often turns out these cats were never more than tolerant roommates. No allogrooming, never slept together in one bed, and many of them have been adopted separately. The owners’ perception of the cats’ relationship before the incident was often better than it was. 

But it can also happen to two cats that grew up together or siblings. As mentioned before, this phenomenon has not been researched. Which brings us back to the fact that cat relationships are fluid. Cat owners should watch for body language and behaviors such as staring, stalking, or resource guarding, and intervene before things get worse.

References:

Beaver, B. V. (2004). Fractious cats and feline aggression. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 6(1), 13–18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfms.2003.09.011

Blanchard, R. J., Blanchard, D. C., Rodgers, J., & Weiss, S. M. (1990). The characterization and modelling of antipredator defensive behavior. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 14(4), 463–472. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0149-7634(05)80069-7

Rodan, I., Ramos, D., Carney, H., DePorter, T., Horwitz, D. F., Mills, D., & Vitale, K. (2024). 2024 AAFP intercat tension guidelines: Recognition, prevention and management. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 26(7). https://doi.org/10.1177/1098612x241263465

Siegel, A., Roeling, T. A. P., Gregg, T. R., & Kruk, M. R. (1999). Neuropharmacology of brain-stimulation-evoked aggression.

Siegel, A., & Shaikh, M. B. (1997). THE NEURAL BASES OF AGGRESSION AND RAGE IN THE CAT.

Next
Next

How to handle fearful cats and kittens?